
The Seventh Circuit’s decision in Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services, 182 F.4th 532 (7th Cir. 2026), handed telemarketers a ridiculously anti-consumer argument: a text message isn’t a “telephone call,” so § 227(c)(5) doesn’t reach it. Defendants in the Fifth Circuit keep trying it. District courts in the Fifth Circuit keep saying no, for the most part. Read v. Kits Eyecare, Ltd., 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 257247 (W.D. Tex. Nov. 6, 2026), is the latest.
The plaintiff alleged he received dozens of telemarketing texts from an eyecare company after putting his cell number on the National Do-Not-Call Registry. He asked them to stop. They didn’t. When he tried calling the number back to make a do-not-call request, he was blocked. The number also carried incomplete caller ID. That’s a lot of contact for someone who never asked for any.
The defendant moved to dismiss. It argued that texts aren’t actionable under § 227(c)(5) and that there’s no private right of action for caller ID violations. It also asked the Court to freeze discovery in the meantime.
On texts, the Court did its own statutory homework, as Loper Bright requires. In 1990, “call” meant “to get or try to get into communication by telephone.” A text, the Court reasoned, is simply a later innovation that does exactly that. It expressly declined to follow Steidinger. It sided instead with courts in the Fifth Circuit that “have consistently found § 227(c) applies to text messages,” including Feliciano v. Red McCombs Hyundai Nw., L.L.C. and Callier v. Finish Line Inc.
The plaintiff's caller ID count survived too. The defendant pointed out that 47 C.F.R. § 64.1601(e) has no cause of action of its own. The Court called that “misplaced,” because regulations never create private rights of action; statutes do. Relying on Starling v. Homeover General Contractors and Newell v. JR Capital, LLC, the Court traced the caller ID rule to § 227(c), which comes with a private right of action.
The discovery stay? Denied, because “a pending motion to dismiss is alone insufficient to overcome the presumption in favor of discovery.”
The dismissal rulings are a recommendation, and the parties have fourteen days to object. The stay denial took effect immediately.