TCPA (Spam Calls & Texts)

Court Denies the General's motion to dismiss TCPA text message class action

Published on
November 17, 2026
Court Denies the General's motion to dismiss TCPA text message class action

Add another one to the Texas pile. In Waterman v. General Automobile Insurance Services, Inc., No. SA-26-CV-03721-JKP, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 261814 (W.D. Tex. Nov. 16, 2026), the Western District of Texas denied an auto insurer’s (the General) motion to dismiss a putative Do-Not-Call class action built on telemarketing texts. The defendant threw five arguments at the complaint, all denied.

The defendant led with the argument making the rounds nationwide: a text is not a “telephone call,” so § 227(c)(5) doesn’t reach it.

The Court acknowledged “a growing split among district and circuit courts” and then declined to relive it. “This Court will not discuss this jurisprudence because it is thoroughly discussed in Duron,” the Court wrote, referring to Duron v. Kings Capital Holding LLC. It then lined up a string of decisions from Texas and elsewhere in the Fifth Circuit, including Feliciano v. Red McCombs Hyundai, Callier v. The Finish Line, Callier v. American Auto Group, Alvarez v. Fiesta Nissan, and McGonigle v. Shopperschoice.com, and joined them.

The bottom line: “the term ‘telephone call’ incorporates text messages under the TCPA.” The Fifth Circuit hasn’t weighed in, but the district courts below it are speaking with one voice.

The General also tried an alternate theory: § 227(c)(5) only lets consumers enforce regulations the FCC adopted by 1992, which would leave the 2003 Do-Not-Call rules out of reach. Its support was Internicola v. MortgagePros, LLC, a terrible September 2026 decision out of the Middle District of Florida. The Court called Internicola a “nonbinding, out-of-circuit district court decision” and declined to follow it “in light of this long-standing jurisprudence to the contrary,” citing Krakauer v. Dish Network and Murray v. Grocery Delivery E-Services, among others.

The defendant next argued that nothing tied the texts to it. The texts, however, introduced the General by name, quoted the plaintiff a price for insurance, assigned her a “quote ID,” and linked to the defendant’s website. That was enough for direct liability. It’s hard to disown a text that hands out your quote IDs.

The last two arguments fared no better. The plaintiff adequately alleged future harm to seek an injunction, despite the defendant’s point that the texts came over three days with “no contact since.” And the motion to strike the class allegations was “premature” because discovery hadn’t started and no certification motion had been filed.

Solid consumer-friendly order here. Great stuff.

Contributors
Garrett Berg
Founder, Consumer Nation
Subscribe to newsletter
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.